Frameworks

What are the SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria?

Direct answer

The Trust Services Criteria (TSC) are the standards the AICPA publishes against which an independent CPA firm evaluates a service organization's controls. There are five categories. Security (Common Criteria, CC) is mandatory and appears in every SOC 2 report. The other four are optional: Availability (A), Processing Integrity (PI), Confidentiality (C), and Privacy (P).

Organizations include them where relevant to the services they provide and to what buyers need to see. Most SaaS companies scope Security as the baseline and add Availability when uptime commitments matter to buyers, Confidentiality when enterprise data handling is a selling point, Privacy when the service processes significant personal data, and Processing Integrity for transactional or financial processing. The Common Criteria are further divided into CC1 through CC9. CC6 covers logical and physical access controls: provisioning, authentication, role-based access, and periodic access review. CC7 covers systems operations and monitoring. CC9 covers risk management and vendor risk, including CC9.2, which requires monitoring of third-party providers and the controls they operate on your behalf. CC6 maps closely to ISO 27001 A.5.15 to A.5.18; CC9.2 to A.5.19 to A.5.23. Organizations running both frameworks reuse this evidence rather than maintaining separate control sets.

What does each of the five categories cover?

The AICPA document that sets out the criteria defines each category in one line:

  • Security. Information and systems are protected against unauthorized access, unauthorized disclosure of information and damage to systems that could compromise the availability, integrity, confidentiality and privacy of information or systems.
  • Availability. Information and systems are available for operation and use to meet the entity’s objectives. The AICPA notes that this does not set a minimum performance level by itself; it addresses whether systems include controls that support accessibility for operation, monitoring and maintenance.
  • Processing integrity. System processing is complete, valid, accurate, timely and authorized.
  • Confidentiality. Information designated as confidential is protected, from its collection or creation through its final disposal.
  • Privacy. Personal information is collected, used, retained, disclosed and disposed of to meet the entity’s objectives.

Confidentiality and Privacy are easy to confuse. Confidentiality applies to any sensitive information, such as trade secrets or intellectual property, while Privacy applies only to personal information and adds requirements on notice, choice and consent, collection, use and retention, access, disclosure, quality and monitoring.

How are the criteria organised?

The criteria are aligned with the 17 principles of the COSO internal control framework, revised in 2013. Those principles become the first five series of the common criteria:

  • CC1, control environment
  • CC2, communication and information
  • CC3, risk assessment
  • CC4, monitoring of controls
  • CC5, control activities

The AICPA then adds supplemental criteria that build on COSO principle 12 on policies and procedures: CC6 for logical and physical access controls, CC7 for system operations, CC8 for change management and CC9 for risk mitigation, which covers business disruption (CC9.1) and vendors and business partners (CC9.2).

The common criteria are enough to evaluate Security; no further criteria are needed. Each optional category adds its own series on top: A1.1 to A1.3 for Availability (capacity, environmental protections and backup and recovery, and testing of recovery plan procedures), PI1.1 to PI1.5 for Processing Integrity, C1.1 and C1.2 for Confidentiality, and the P series for Privacy. A category counts as addressed only when all of its criteria are addressed. In limited cases a single criterion can be not applicable, for example P3.1 on collection for a service organization that does not collect personal information directly from data subjects.

What are points of focus, and do you have to meet all of them?

Each criterion comes with points of focus, which the AICPA describes, following COSO, as important characteristics of the criterion. They help management design and operate controls, and help the auditor judge whether controls were suitably designed and operated effectively.

They are not a checklist. The AICPA states that using the criteria does not require an assessment of whether each point of focus is addressed, and that some may not be suitable or relevant to a given entity. The auditor’s opinion is on the criteria. The current AICPA edition is the 2017 Trust Services Criteria with revised points of focus published in 2022.

How do you decide which categories to include?

Start from what you have promised. In a SOC 2 examination, the AICPA ties the entity’s objectives to its commitments to customers and its system requirements. Commitments are what management declares about the performance of its systems, usually in contracts, service level agreements or public statements such as a privacy notice.

  • An uptime commitment in your contracts points to Availability.
  • Contract clauses that restrict how you use or keep customer data point to Confidentiality.
  • A privacy notice and personal data at the core of the service point to Privacy.
  • Transactions or calculations your customers rely on point to Processing Integrity.

The most common mistake is adding categories for the look of the report. Every category you add brings all of its criteria into scope, and each needs controls with evidence for the whole period. Map the criteria you choose to your existing controls first, see cross-framework control mapping.

How Acuna GRC handles it

Sources

  1. AICPA, 2017 Trust Services Criteria (With Revised Points of Focus, 2022), TSP section 100
  2. AICPA & CIMA, SOC 3 general use report (the five categories)

This page explains the rules in general terms and is not legal advice.

Frequently asked

Are the Trust Services Criteria only used for SOC 2?

No. The AICPA designed them for several engagements: SOC 2 and SOC 3 examinations, SOC for Cybersecurity, SOC for Supply Chain, and readiness work performed as a consulting engagement.

Who writes the Trust Services Criteria?

The AICPA’s Assurance Services Executive Committee (ASEC). It followed due process, including exposure of the criteria for public comment, and the AICPA treats criteria from this body as suitable criteria for attestation engagements.

Does every SOC 2 report include all nine CC series?

Yes, the common criteria CC1 to CC9 apply to every category, because they are shared across all five. What changes from one report to another is which additional category series are added on top.

See how Acuna GRC runs this.

Tell us your frameworks and your team. We show you how Acuna GRC runs the program.

Hosted in Switzerland, the EU or the US