What is a Transfer Impact Assessment (TIA)?
Direct answer
A Transfer Impact Assessment (TIA) is the analysis GDPR Chapter V requires before personal data goes to a country outside the EU or EEA without an adequacy decision. Since Schrems II, Standard Contractual Clauses alone are not enough: you assess whether the destination's law and practice give essentially equivalent protection, then apply supplementary measures or stop the transfer.
A Transfer Impact Assessment (TIA) is the analysis required under GDPR Chapter V before transferring personal data to a country outside the EU or EEA without an adequacy decision. Following Schrems II, relying on Standard Contractual Clauses alone is insufficient: you must assess whether the destination country's law and practice provide essentially equivalent protection and, where it falls short, apply supplementary measures or stop the transfer.
When do you need a TIA, and when not?
A TIA is needed when you rely on an Article 46 transfer tool, such as the Commission’s standard contractual clauses or binding corporate rules, to send personal data outside the EEA. The EDPB’s Recommendations 01/2020 treat remote access from a third country, for example in support situations, and storage in a cloud outside the EEA as transfers too.
It is not needed where the destination has an adequacy decision under Article 45. You then only monitor that the decision stays valid. For the United States, the Commission’s adequacy decision of 10 July 2023 on the EU-US Data Privacy Framework (Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795) covers organisations certified under that framework, not every US recipient.
The Article 49 derogations, such as explicit consent or necessity for a contract with the person, are the last resort. The EDPB says they cannot become the rule in practice and must be restricted to specific situations.
The standard contractual clauses make the assessment a contractual duty. Under Clause 14 of the clauses adopted by Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914 of 4 June 2021, the parties warrant that they have no reason to believe the destination’s laws and practices prevent the importer from meeting its obligations, and agree to document that assessment and make it available to the competent supervisory authority on request.
What does a TIA assess?
Clause 14(b) lists three elements to take into account:
- The specific circumstances of the transfer: the length of the processing chain, the number of actors and the transmission channels, onward transfers, the type of recipient, the purpose, the categories and format of the data, the economic sector and where the data is stored.
- The laws and practices of the destination country, including those requiring disclosure to public authorities or authorising their access, relevant to the transfer, and the limitations and safeguards that apply.
- Any contractual, technical or organisational safeguards added to the clauses, including measures during transmission and processing in the destination country.
The EDPB frames the work in six steps: know your transfers, identify the transfer tool, assess whether it is effective in the destination country, adopt supplementary measures where needed, take any procedural steps those measures require, and re-evaluate at appropriate intervals. Mapping starts from your record of processing activities, and it includes onward transfers by your processors to sub-processors in other countries.
What if the assessment finds a gap?
You adopt supplementary measures that bring the protection up to the EU standard of essential equivalence. The EDPB’s Recommendations give a non-exhaustive list of technical, contractual and organisational examples and stress that a measure effective for one country may not be effective in another, so several may need to be combined.
If no measure can close the gap, you must avoid, suspend or end the transfer. The clauses build this in. The importer must promptly notify the exporter if it has reason to believe it is, or has become, subject to laws or practices that do not meet the standard, for example after a change in law or a disclosure request (Clause 14(e)). The exporter must then identify measures, and suspend the transfer if it considers no appropriate safeguards can be ensured or if the competent supervisory authority instructs it to (Clause 14(f)).
A TIA is not a one-time file. Re-evaluate it when laws, recipients or the data change, and record the result. Infringements of the transfer rules in Articles 44 to 49 fall under the higher tier of fines in Article 83(5)(c).
How do transfers from Switzerland work?
Article 16 of the revised FADP follows a similar logic. Personal data may be disclosed abroad where the Federal Council has found that the destination provides an adequate level of protection; the list is in Annex 1 of the Data Protection Ordinance. Since 15 September 2024, that annex includes the United States for organisations certified under the Swiss-US Data Privacy Framework.
Without an adequacy finding, an appropriate level of protection must be guaranteed by one of the instruments in Article 16(2), for example data protection clauses notified to the FDPIC beforehand, standard data protection clauses the FDPIC has approved, issued or recognised, or binding corporate rules approved by the FDPIC or by the authority of a country with adequate protection. A controller using standard clauses must take appropriate measures to ensure that the recipient complies with them (Article 10 of the Ordinance). Article 17 lists narrow exceptions, such as explicit consent. See does the GDPR apply to Swiss companies?
How Acuna GRC handles it
Data Privacy in Acuna GRC pre-fills the TIA safeguard from the transfers already recorded on a processing activity and computes the transfer risk with a default of High, so a transfer has to earn a lower rating rather than be assumed safe.
- Module
Data Privacy
Processing activities, data inventory and flows, DPIAs, DPAs, TIAs, data subject requests and breaches, with a public privacy portal.
- Module
TPRM (Supplier Shield)
Suppliers, questionnaires, assessments and campaigns, with a supplier portal and supplier risk intelligence: daily scans condensed into an A to F grade, with breach and sanctions checks.
- Solution
GDPR
Meet GDPR accountability: keep the Art. 30 record current, assess high-risk processing under Art. 35 and prove each request and breach met its deadline.
- Solution
Swiss FADP
Meet your revFADP duties: a record of processing, impact assessments for high-risk processing, access requests and breach reports to the FDPIC, with the GDPR.
Sources
- EDPB Recommendations 01/2020 on measures that supplement transfer tools, version 2.0
- Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914 on standard contractual clauses for transfers to third countries, Clause 14 and Article 4
- Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795 on the EU-US Data Privacy Framework
- Court of Justice, judgment of 16 July 2020, Case C-311/18 (Schrems II)
- Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP), Articles 16 and 17
- Data Protection Ordinance (DPO), Article 10 and Annex 1
This page explains the rules in general terms and is not legal advice.
Frequently asked
Did Schrems II invalidate the standard contractual clauses?
No. In its judgment of 16 July 2020 in Case C-311/18, the Court of Justice invalidated the EU-US Privacy Shield decision and upheld the standard contractual clauses decision then in force, while requiring exporters to check, case by case, that the protection is essentially equivalent in practice.
Can we still use the old standard contractual clauses?
No. Decision 2001/497/EC and Decision 2010/87/EU were repealed with effect from 27 September 2021. Contracts concluded before that date on the old clauses were deemed to provide appropriate safeguards only until 27 December 2022, so transfers now need the 2021 clauses or another tool.
Is remote access to EU data from a third country a transfer?
Yes. The EDPB’s Recommendations 01/2020 state that remote access by an entity in a third country to data located in the EEA, for example for support, is a transfer, and so is storage with a cloud provider outside the EEA.
See how Acuna GRC runs this.
Tell us your frameworks and your team. We show you how Acuna GRC runs the program.
Hosted in Switzerland, the EU or the US
.png&w=3840&q=75&dpl=dpl_96PxuEbyzwoWxjweCh9wLaGaDCHP)

